Posted by: Scott | November 2, 2009

The Lager/Ale Enigma

Remember to click on unfamiliar words for an explanation on the beer terms page!

FIGHT!“My friend wants an ale, but I’ll just have a beer.” Have you ever heard that (or some variation thereof) in a bar or liquor store? I sure have. Most casual beer fans seem to know that lagers and ales differ in some way. Yet many are unaware of the pair’s major similarity: They’re both beer. In fact, they’re the only types of beer available; each keg and bottle contains either a lager or an ale. Sure, a few hybrid styles blur the lines a bit, but I’m trying to keep this article simple (don’t hurt me, fellow beer nerds!). So, what’s the oversimplified difference between the two?

The science mostly involves fermentation temperatures and yeast strains. Humans discovered top-fermenting ale yeasts first, primarily via wild strains that leap into action at warmer temperatures, produce beer quickly, and can ferment outdoors. Brewers later encountered lager yeasts while trying to refrigerate reserves in caves. Instead of preserving their ale yeasts, this idea killed the little guys—and revealed the bottom-fermenting yeasts that thrive in lower temperatures.

So what does this top-and-bottom junk mean to the average boozehound? Not much. We’re discussing living organisms, and they rarely play by the rules. But for the most part, speedy ale yeasts produce flavorful, complex beers. Chilled-out lager yeasts, on the other hand, convert sugars more slowly and manufacture fewer fruity esters, which often creates a lighter body and cleaner flavors. As a result, many lagers’ crisp floral notes perform well when served cold (but not too cold), whereas many ales start to bloom as they warm up.

In terms of substyles, lagers comprise everything from light pilsners to dark, complex doppelbocks (some beers happily shatter lager/ale stereotypes!). Ales have barleywines, IPAs, porters, stouts, and many more. My favorite? Well, I believe there are worthwhile beers in every category—but I’m definitely an ale man. Unless I’m in the mood for a beer instead.


Coming up on Thursday: My review of a Hawaiian coconut porter!



  1. Nice write up. Generally speaking, I’m an ale man too, but there are some lagers that I enjoy as well. I think there is more variation in Ale world than Lager world.

    • Thanks! And I definitely agree. I really do enjoy a good lager once and a while, but nothing beats a nice, dark, complex ale!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: